Let's discuss how we can help.

When selecting an orchestration tool for data engineering workflows, two leading platforms stand out: Apache Airflow and Dagster. Both tools excel at managing data pipelines, but they take fundamentally different approaches to orchestration. This comparison evaluates both tools across key metrics relevant to modern data engineering requirements.

: Task-centric orchestration focusing on workflow execution

Tasks represent discrete units of work (running scripts, queries, data transfers)

: Assets (data products produced by operations/ops)

: Data-centric approach emphasizing data dependencies and lineage

Assets represent data entities with explicit inputs, outputs, and metadata

: Dagster for data-centric workflows, Airflow for task-based orchestration

1. Data Tracking, Lineage, Dependency Visualization, and Quality Checks

: ✅ Basic task-level monitoring and logging

Requires integration with OpenLineage or custom solutions

Task dependencies are visible, but data dependencies are not explicit

Shows task dependencies but not data lineage

Requires integration with external tools (Great Expectations, dbt tests, etc.)

Must implement custom operators for validation

Automatic tracking of data asset dependencies and transformations

: ✅ Asset dependency graph with detailed metadata

Visual representation of data flows and asset relationships

: Dagster (significantly more robust out-of-the-box)

2. Data Definitions (Asset Specifications)

Data passing between tasks uses XComs (cross-communication)

XComs can be opaque and difficult to manage in complex workflows

Data definitions are implicit within task logic

No standardized framework for defining data schemas or specifications

✅ Software-defined assets as core concept

Support for asset observations and materializations

: Dagster (clear advantage with explicit asset modeling)

3. Isolation of Dependencies (Code Locations)

⚠️ Supports dependency isolation through:

Docker containers (KubernetesExecutor, DockerOperator)

Different executors (LocalExecutor, CeleryExecutor, KubernetesExecutor)

Requires manual configuration and maintenance

No standardized approach for modular deployments

Separate environments for different pipeline parts

Blog

Dagster vs Airflow: A Comprehensive Comparison for Data Orchestration